Rep. Scott Peters is co-sponsoring a carbon removal bill
Rep. Scott Peters at the region’s 2026 Congressional luncheon in June. (File photo by Thomas Murphy/Times of San Diego)

Rep. Scott Peters is urging his colleagues to pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, a proposal to overhaul federal environmental review and permitting processes for energy and infrastructure projects.

But his push faces opposition from conservation advocates and Peters’ fellow California Democrats. The Senate approved the bill late Thursday, with both California Sens. Alex Padilla and Adam Schiff voting against it.

It now needs approval in the House during the lame-duck session before newly elected officials are sworn in next year.

House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries said he supports permitting reform, but BAAJA “falls short in several areas.” Some Democrats have argued their new majority means they could pass a bill is more focused on their priorities, but Peters said the bill’s boost to clean energy is a win his colleagues should be happy to take. 

“This is going to transform the way we build energy and give clean energy a chance to compete,” Peters said. “It’s going to lower emissions, lower costs, and it’s going to provide jobs.

“We’re just so used to everything taking forever in the United States of America because of this red tape,” he said. “The environmental laws need to be modernized, and this does that in a way that protects the environment and even lowers emissions.”

Some climate and environmental activists, though, argue BAAJA does too much for the fossil fuel industry for the clean energy gains to matter.

Neal Desai, the senior Pacific regional director of the National Parks Conservation Association, said the bill has “too many damaging provisions that outweigh any potential benefits.

“When we look at what this bill actually does … we’re looking at who is it providing the keys to, and what is the agenda there,” he said. “And that’s deeply troubling because this administration has shown that they will absolutely disregard the law to implement their agenda.”

Desai and other environmental advocates argue the legislation would allow permits to be “locked in,” preventing future administrations from changing or canceling potentially harmful developments.

Peters pushed back on the concern, reasoning that “the administration can only approve things that are legal.”

Environmental organizations are focused on a section of BAAJA that effectively prevents future administrations from revoking or changing federal permits already granted to privately sponsored projects — even if they believe those permits were issued in violation of federal law. There are narrow exceptions for fraud, immediate safety risks or permit violations. 

Supporters of the bill, like Peters, see this as a way to prevent President Donald Trump from halting existing projects — like the five offshore wind projects the administration suspended in 2025.

Another section of BAAJA would make it harder for courts to stop environmentally harmful projects, even when the government violates the National Environmental Policy Act. Rather than blocking a project or invalidating a permit, courts could only send the decision back to the agency and require it to try again.  

“The whole idea is baffling … It’s just really tough to see how this bill could drive the clean energy agenda, given how there’s so much stuff in here that has nothing to do with even energy,” Desai said. 

He said the Trump administration supports the bill because it boosts environmentally harmful activities, like mining.

“If you care about our national parks and other public lands, and clean water and clean air, this bill has too many damaging provisions that outweigh any potential benefits,” Desai said.

He cited a proposed 20,000-acre mining development on the border of Joshua Tree National Park. 

“These are all the types of permits and things that would be locked in,” he said.  

The bill is also opposed by 11 tribal organizations, including the Native American Rights Fund, the National Indian Child Welfare Association and the National Congress of American Indians over the attempts to “undermine Tribal sovereignty” — the same issue identified by Padilla ahead of his vote against the bill Thursday. 

Padilla led numerous Senate Democrats in an amendment to exempt tribal governments from provisions designed to make it more difficult to file lawsuits seeking to halt a project.

As the bill stands, Tribes would be limited in their ability to protect lands and culturally significant places from proposed projects with federal connections. The Native American Rights Fund said the bill is “stripping cultural protection and Tribal participation” under the National Historic Preservation Act.

“Tribal Nations should not be forced to bear the brunt of these cultural and spiritual harms so the nation can further develop and transport its energy resources,” read a joint letter from Tribal organizations.  “We have already sacrificed the majority of our lands and natural resources — oftentimes through force or coercion — upon which the United States has become the world power it is today.”

Peters said he would like to see clarity for Tribal nations, but ultimately thinks it’s a good bill with a few trade-offs.

“I would like to see some clarification about what the rights of Tribal nations are in the consultation process. I think that needs to be better defined,” he said. “But I think it’s a really good bill as it is.”

Peters said “every clean energy producer is supporting this bill,” because it would speed up a permitting process that often “kills the project because they can’t keep the financing together.”

The congressman said he would like to see more utility-scale solar projects in rural parts of California. 

“Oil and gas is already way ahead of renewables,” he said. “This is going to give wind and solar a chance to compete. That’s why all analysis shows that overall emissions go down as a result of BAAJA. This is definitely a clean energy bill, not a dirty energy bill.”