Automated License Plate Reader (File photo by Thomas Melville/Times of San Diego)

The San Diego City Council on Monday took sweeping action on surveillance policies, unanimously voting to suspend the use of automated license plate readers.

But in a surprise move, the council also voted to halt the city’s Smart Streetlights program.

The steps opened the door to ending the city’s contract with Flock Safety and Ubicquia, another less infamous AI-powered camera system.

Ahead of the 7-0 ALPR vote, Councilmember Henry Foster III proposed reconsidering the city’s Smart Streetlights policy as well. That’s because the two camera systems cannot be unbundled in the city’s nearly $12 million contract. 

The council was divided on that decision, rejecting the Smart Streetlights use policy in a 5-2 vote.  Councilmembers Vivian Moreno and Raul Campillo voted nay, with Jen Campbell and Marni von Wilpert absent for the key votes.

Police defend ALPRs as important crime-fighting tools, but privacy advocates have raised alarms about the vast amount of data the technology collects, who has access to the local information and how it is being used.

Critics have gathered enough momentum that dozens of cities have recently done away with Flock Safety’s cameras.

Those critics took displayed their cross-cutting demographic representation during three hours of public comment before the city council on Monday. Baby Boomers stood alongside millennials singing Fall Out Boy spoofs and Gen Z students citing community surveys.

ALPR opponents take specific issue with Flock Safety, the dominant vendor in the industry.  Many don’t want their data in the hands of Flock, citing fears about the company’s cooperation with ICE. 

But San Diego police didn’t escape the meeting unscathed either.

Many said at the Monday meeting that they do not trust the San Diego Police Department’s use of the technology. Public speakers cited reporting from Times of San Diego showing a false ALPR hit led to a man spending months in jail for a crime he did not commit.

In another instance, also reported by Times of San Diego, an ALPR hit on a stolen car led to an SDPD officer shooting a 19-year-old passenger in the vehicle. The owner said the car had not been stolen.

Most recently, Voice of San Diego reported that SDPD used the technology to track a domestic violence victim during an internal investigation of inappropriate sexual conduct by an officer.

Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, a steadfast critic of the technology, pointed to these instances as justification for his view that police have lost the trust of its residents on this issue.

“I think all these cases share something that should make everyone concerned, and that’s that our justice system rests on a very basic premise: that we’re all innocent until proven guilty. ALPRs seem to turn that whole thing upside down,” he said.

Councilmember Raul Campillo, who switched his position on this issue last week, said the news that police used the technology as part of an internal investigation was more than enough to make him flip.

“The position that the department has taken on that reading, I’m utterly disappointed. And Chief,” he said, addressing police Chief Scott Wahl, “I expected more, given how clear several council members have been about the fears we have about this and the trust that we put in you not just to follow the rules, but to see the bigger picture of what the public expectation was.”

Some council members cited these instances as well, but the most common concern among them was the federal government’s potential use of the data collected by ALPRs.

“My view of the effectiveness of ALPRs hasn’t changed. What has changed is the context,” said Councilmember Stephen Whitburn, who had backed the technology until announcing his reversal last month.

“When this city council initially approved ALPRs three years ago, it was during the Biden administration. A year later, Donald Trump was elected president. The two years since have been a living hell for too many families in our city.” 

But this vote doesn’t spell an immediate end for Flock in San Diego.

The city’s contract with Flock Safety and Ubicquia is still active. However, now that the council has rejected the city’s use policies for both ALPR and Smart Streetlights, it can consider scraping the contract altogether. 

Foster’s motion to vote on Smart Streetlights separately came after Lyndsay Winkley, SDPD’s community liaison manager, told the council that if both pieces of technology are no longer approved, the city could kill the contract. The city could also renegotiate, rather than cancel, the contract.

Despite Mayor Todd Gloria’s support for ALPRs, ahead of the vote he announced he would respect the council’s wishes and not wield his veto power. Gloria’s council affairs adviser, Kohta Zaiser, told the council the city will shut down the system on their end and direct SDPD to initiate the process with Ubicquia and Flock to remove the cameras. He said by the end of this week the mayor’s office should be able to provide the council with a plan to begin dismantling over 500 cameras citywide.

If the city is going to cancel the contract, though, officials must do it sooner rather than later to avoid paying a $2 million fee due in December for services in the coming year.