Rep. Sara Jacobs lost to Illinois Rep. Lauren Underwood Wednesday in a tight, contentious race to be the next vice chair of the House Democratic Caucus.

Jacobs missed out on the No. 6 spot on the Democratic leadership ladder after an anonymous vote of 143-118.

“We have the opportunity to prove that the American people were right to trust us with their votes. We need to break the status quo – not go back to the way things were. It’s time to lower costs, end forever wars, and build the kind of country we actually want,” Jacobs posted on X after the vote. “Let’s get to work.”

A woman sits beside a table with flowers. She is folding her hands in toward her chest while speaking.
Rep. Sara Jacobs in June. (File photo by Thomas Murphy/Times of San Diego)

Jacobs campaigned on her record of experience in conflict resolution as Caucus Leadership Representative during the 118th Congress, her success as a prolific fundraiser and her leadership roles on the Democratic Steering and Policy Committee and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.

But Jacobs couldn’t run away from her California roots.  

Underwood, co-chair of the House Democratic Policy and Communications Committee, brought to the table a Midwestern perspective that breaks up a leadership ladder led by coastal lawmakers.

“I am so honored that my colleagues have put their faith and trust in me to serve as the next Vice Chair of the House Democratic Caucus,” Underwood posted on X after the vote. 

Underwood ran on a platform of revamping caucus’ communications strategy and her history of flipping a Republican seat in rural Illinois into a Democratic stronghold. 

Underwood said before the race she wasn’t worried about the title, but wanted a larger role in the party. 

“I am not necessarily interested in titles. I’m really not,” Underwood said to Once Upon a Hill reporter Michael Jones. “I want to solve problems and I want us to win.” 

Punchbowl News wrote on Tuesday that Jacobs was “widely seen as the favorite” going into leadership votes.

The nominations for House Democratic leadership are Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of New York as speaker, Rep. Katherine Clark of Massachusetts as majority leader, Rep. Pete Aguilar of California as majority whip, Rep. Joe Neguse of Colorado as assistant speaker and Rep. Ted Lieu of California as caucus chair. 

Underwood, 40, will be the highest-ranking Black woman ever elected to House leadership. 

Underwood paid homage to Shirley Chrisholm in her X post announcing her victory. Chisholm was the first black woman ever elected to Congress and served as assistant secretary and secretary of the House Democratic Caucus during her tenure. 

“In the words of the great Shirley Chisholm: ‘Service is the rent we pay for the privilege of living on this earth,’” Underwood posted. “I walk in her footsteps today, and I’m ready to get (to) work helping our team WIN on behalf of our communities.”

The consensus among many lawmakers was that both congresswomen were fit for the job. Rep. Bennie Thompson, a member of the Congressional Black Caucus, told The Hill they “had two good choices.” 

The vote to elect Jeffries as Speaker of the House will take place on Jan. 3 when the Democrat-controlled 120th Congress convenes following historic midterm wins. After the election and swearing-in of the speaker, the remaining members of the House will be sworn into office, and the newly elected party leadership will officially assume their roles.