This article first appeared in EdSource.
One of Xavier Becerra’s first major tasks after taking office as governor on Jan. 4 will be to appoint the state’s first education commissioner, who will oversee a reorganization of the California Department of Education.
EdSource surveyed more than a dozen California education leaders about the qualities Becerra should look for in an education commissioner and who might be capable of leading the effort to fix a system long considered fragmented and unresponsive to school districts’ needs.
“We have a very diffused system. We need to coordinate it, organize it, point it in the right direction and get it to work,” said Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the California State Board of Education.
That fragmented system is one reason Gov. Gavin Newsom and state legislators passed legislation in July to reorganize the department. The legislation followed a report by Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE) recommending realigning roles and responsibilities to create a more coherent education governance system.
“We have a history in our state of these really ambitious reforms that are adopted with very little state guidance and support,” said Julie Marsh, a co-author of the report. “We need someone to come in and make the department a place that can ensure consistent implementation across the state.”
Wanted: Education Commissioner
California is seeking an experienced leader who can reorganize the state’s education system, navigate complicated politics and advance student achievement. Here are the 10 qualities that 16 education leaders say are essential for the job:
- Strong leadership experience in K-12 education.
- Experience leading an organization through major change.
- Respect and credibility within the education community.
- Ability to navigate Sacramento politics.
- Deep knowledge of California’s education system.
- A commitment to improving student achievement.
- Ability to build consensus among diverse stakeholders.
- Appreciation for data and research.
- Strong leadership, vision and integrity.
- A deep understanding of teaching and learning.
The education leaders surveyed came up with a list of top contenders that included state superintendents, county superintendents, a former deputy superintendent, a small charter school leader and the CEO of a nonprofit.
Education leaders have a lengthy list of qualifications for the job, but nearly all agree that the new commissioner should have experience leading a complex organization, improving student academic outcomes and overseeing systemwide change. The person should also understand California’s complicated education system, know how to navigate Sacramento politics and build a strong relationship with the governor.
Most of those interviewed by EdSource say the commissioner should have experience running a school district, preferably a large one, while also understanding the challenges facing smaller and rural districts.
“We’re looking for a unicorn, someone who also understands how California politics work, how to navigate the Legislature, someone who works well with others,” said Rene Rickard, president of the Association of California School Administrators and chief innovation officer at the Ventura Unified School District.
The short list
There is a lot of speculation in the education community about who might be a good fit for the job. Although Becerra did not respond to a request from EdSource for an interview, education leaders say there are plenty of names being bandied about.
They include Ed Manansala, El Dorado County superintendent of schools; Jorge Aguilar, superintendent of Wonderful College Prep Academy; Rick Miller, executive director of CORE Districts; Paul Gothold, former San Diego County superintendent of schools; Tony Smith, former Illinois State Superintendent of Education; Cindy Marten, Delaware Secretary of Education; and Karla Estrada, a former deputy superintendent of Los Angeles Unified.
Two of the candidates who made the short list — Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the State Board of Education, and Brooks Allen, the state board’s executive director — told EdSource they are not interested in the position.
There have been a lot of conversations among the state’s education leaders about whether the new commissioner should be a dynamic visionary leader who can transform the department or a skilled administrator who can manage a complex organization.
Ted Lempert, president of Children Now, which rallied support for the CDE reorganization, said the state should not have to choose between the two.
“Those things don’t have to be totally mutually exclusive,” Lempert said. “You can have a strong agency leader who also inspires those that work for them.”
Understanding California a must
Beyond management experience, the new commissioner will need to understand California’s complicated education system — complete with 935 school districts, 58 county offices, the Department of Education and State Board of Education — and the state legislative process.
That is particularly important because the commissioner only has until June 30 to submit an interim report to the Legislature outlining plans to reorganize and streamline education governance in the state.
“They need to know the systems and the people, and the policies and politics,” Darling-Hammond said. “It’s not just the politics. We have a way of working in California.”
An educator should be in charge
After years of former state legislators being elected superintendent of public instruction, many in the education community are ready to see an educator in charge.
Having an educator in charge of the CDE is critical, said Yolie Flores, CEO and president of the nonprofit education advocacy organization Families in Schools.
“I also would like for there to be an individual who is visionary and courageous, and who is willing to do what many are not for political reasons, but because it’s the right thing to do for our kids, for our students,” Flores said.
With about half of California students not proficient in math or English language arts, according to state test scores, the new commissioner also needs a deep understanding of teaching and learning, said Pedro Noguera, dean of the Rossier School of Education at the University of Southern California.
“The reason why I say that is because we’re kind of stuck,” he said. “There have been significant investments in public education in the state, so the state deserves credit for that, but we’re not seeing significant gains in student performance.”
Noguera said the commissioner should ensure that districts receive the guidance they need and have opportunities to share best practices to improve student achievement.
Changing the focus to service
Education leaders also want a commissioner who can transform the CDE from a department focused primarily on oversight into one that better supports school districts, charter schools and county offices of education.
“If this commissioner is going to help the California Department of Education to become more responsive, they first have to hear from those of us who are in the field and what our needs are,” said Nicole Glentzer, Mendocino County superintendent of schools and legislative chair for California County Superintendents.
Louise Simson, superintendent of Mark Twain Union Elementary in Angels Camp, would like the commissioner to be more responsive to the needs of small and rural districts. The district has about 700 students enrolled in three schools.
“I want programs to be flexible for the needs of small, and particularly small, rural districts,” Simson said. “I need somebody to be very understanding that we’re in trouble with declining enrollment, and that these temporary solutions are Band-Aids. We’re going to have catastrophic closures if we don’t figure out how to backfill the funds from declining enrollment.”
The appointment of a commissioner should transform the California Department of Education, said Lempert of Children Now.
“What I would love to see when this person is announced is that superintendents around the state say, ‘Wow, this really is a new day,’” he said.
Cindy Marten, Delaware Secretary of Education
The buzz: Marten is considered a strong potential candidate because of her experience at the national, state and local level. Education leaders say she has a reputation as an ethical leader and works well with unions.
Experience: Marten has served as Delaware’s Secretary of Education since January 2025. Before that, she was deputy secretary of the U.S. Department of Education for four years and superintendent of San Diego Unified School District for eight years. She began her career as a classroom teacher, spending 17 years in the classroom before becoming a principal, a position she held for another decade.
Career highlights: At the U.S. Department of Education, Marten was in charge of a $230 billion budget and more than 4,000 employees, according to her online bio. During her tenure at San Diego Unified, the district achieved the highest graduation rate of large urban districts in California and the fastest reading growth among major U.S. districts.
Education: Marten earned a bachelor’s degree in education from the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse, and a master’s degree in teaching and learning from UC San Diego.
She says: Marten could not be reached for comment for this story.
Ed Manansala, El Dorado County superintendent of schools
The buzz: Manansala was a popular choice for the job among education leaders surveyed by EdSource. They describe him as a collaborative leader with strong ethics who is focused on the needs of students. Although much of his career has been spent in local and county education leadership, his service on numerous statewide boards has given him a broader perspective on California education, they said.
Experience: Manansala has worked at the El Dorado County Office of Education for 13 years, first as its deputy superintendent then its superintendent. Before that Manansala was chief of staff at Sacramento City Unified and principal, superintendent and director of strategic partnerships for St. Hope Public Schools, a charter school system in Sacramento.
Career highlights: As El Dorado County schools chief, Manansala helped establish a countywide commission for youth and families, a teacher residency program and Mountainside Middle College High School, which allows students to earn college credits while earning a high school diploma. During his five years at St. Hope, he significantly increased graduation and college acceptance rates.
Education: Manansala earned bachelor’s and master’s degrees in business administration from Sacramento State, and a doctorate in educational leadership from UC Davis.
He says: Manansala did not comment for this story.
Jorge Aguilar, Superintendent of Wonderful College Prep Academy
The buzz: Education leaders say Aguilar relies on data and research to guide his decisions. They describe him as intelligent and well respected, although one expert said he lacks statewide experience and is not well liked by teachers unions.
Experience: Aguilar is superintendent of Wonderful College Prep Academy, a charter school serving students in Lost Hills and Delano. Before that, he was superintendent of Sacramento City Unified for six years, associate superintendent of Fresno Unified for eight years and a vice chancellor at UC Merced for 24 years. Aguilar began his career as a Spanish teacher at L.A. Unified’s South Gate High School.
Career highlights: The son of farmworkers in the Central Valley and a former participant in the Migrant Education Program, Aguilar has been a champion for equity and access in education, according to the Carnegie Foundation, where Aguilar serves on the board of trustees. The foundation also credits him with improving student academic performance and reducing dropout rates.
Education: Aguilar earned a bachelor’s degree in Latin American studies, Spanish and Portuguese from UC Berkeley and a juris doctorate from Loyola Law School in Los Angeles.
He says: Aguilar could not be reached for comment on this story.
Karla V. Estrada, Former deputy superintendent of instruction LAUSD
The buzz: Education leaders described Estrada as “brilliant,” “sharp” and “amazing.” They credit her with helping drive recent academic progress in L.A. Unified. Her experience in Boston and in California give her a broad perspective, one education leader said.
Experience: Estrada served as deputy superintendent of instruction at Los Angeles Unified for four years before resigning in June. Before that, she was chief academic officer at Council of the Great City Schools in Washington, D.C. for six months, senior advisor and then deputy executive director at the California Collaborative for Educational Excellence for three years, deputy superintendent of Boston Public Schools for three years and an area administrator for LAUSD for three years.
Career highlights: During Estrada’s tenure at L.A. Unified, the district’s academic improvement outpaced the state and most districts nationally, according to the Los Angeles Times.
Education: Estrada earned a bachelor’s degree from Cal State Northridge and a doctoral degree in education leadership for social justice from Loyola Marymount University.
She says: Estrada could not be reached for comment for this story.
Rick Miller, CEO of CORE Districts
The buzz: Some state education leaders think Miller would be a good choice for the top job, while others question whether he has the experience needed to run a large district. One person surveyed by EdSource said he would make a good deputy commissioner.
Experience: Miller has been CEO of CORE Districts, a learning partnership among eight large California school districts, and a partner in Capitol Impact, a Sacramento consulting firm, since 2010. Before that, he served as a deputy superintendent at the California Department of Education for seven years, public relations manager at Microsoft Corp. for three years, associate director in the California State University’s chancellor’s office for nearly a year and press secretary for U.S. Secretary of Education Richard W. Riley for four years. Miller also served as a school board member in the Rocklin Unified School District from 2018 to December 2022.
Career highlights: Miller founded CORE districts in 2010. It was the first nonstate entity to receive a waiver from No Child Left Behind.
Education: Miller earned a bachelor’s degree in government from California State University, Sacramento, according to his LinkedIn profile.
He says: Miller said he is happy leading Core Districts, but has not ruled out the education commissioner’s job.
“I actually do believe that this is the most significant realignment in my lifetime, the greatest opportunity I’ve seen to bring coherence to an incredibly broken system — literally from the classroom to the governor,” Miller told EdSource. “So the potential here is huge. And I think the possibility of it working is there and available. And so, in that sense, who wouldn’t want to be part of that, right?”
Paul Gothold, retired San Diego County superintendent of schools
The buzz: Many education leaders interviewed by EdSource spoke highly of Gothold, describing him as “fabulous,” “a bold leader” and “very gifted.” At least one, however, wondered whether he would be right for the job because he lacks statewide experience.
Experience: Gothold served as superintendent of the San Diego County Office of Education for seven years, retiring in 2024. Before that, he was superintendent of the Lynwood Unified School District for four years. He also served as a site leader in the district. He began his career as a teacher in Los Angeles County.
Career highlights: During his tenure in San Diego, Gothold championed initiatives to bring more innovation into classrooms and to close the digital divide in underserved schools and districts. In 2021, he created an educational program for unaccompanied minors from Mexico, holding classes twice a week at a temporary shelter at the San Diego Convention Center for four months.
At Lynwood Unified, he made systemwide changes that improved students’ academic performance, increased graduation rates and put the district on firmer financial footing.
Education: Gothold earned a bachelor’s degree in business from Whittier College and a doctorate in education from the University of Southern California.
He says: Gothold could not be reached for comment for this story.
Tony Smith, former Illinois superintendent of schools
The buzz: Education leaders overall liked Smith’s broad experience as a superintendent and a state education leader.
Experience: Smith is co-founder and CEO of Whyspeople, a consulting firm. He was also deputy superintendent of innovation at the San Diego County Office of Education for almost two years, Illinois State Superintendent of Education for four years, superintendent of Oakland Unified for four years, superintendent of Emeryville Unified for 3.5 years, deputy superintendent of San Francisco Unified for almost two years and executive director of a nonprofit in Chicago for two years.
Career Highlights: As Illinois chief education officer, Smith led the state Board of Education through a two-year state budget impasse and passage of the Evidence-Based Funding Formula. While Smith led Oakland Unified, the district launched a full-service community schools strategy, created the office of African American Male Achievement and eliminated a structural deficit while improving student outcomes.
Education: Earned a bachelor’s degree in English, a master’s degree in Education and a doctorate in Language, Literacy, and Culture from UC Berkeley.
He says: Under his leadership, Smith said the Illinois education system focused on supporting the state’s school districts. “That’s what the department should be like, facilitating, connecting and kind of coordinating, aligning, leveraging all the assets possible,” Smith said.
Smith indicated he could be open to accepting the job if asked, calling the opportunity amazing. “The conversation has to be one with the governor about what the governor expects and what he thinks it should do. … If, in fact, the governor sees it as supporting the department to be in service to those districts and be a resource and an asset, I’d absolutely consider that because it’s desperately needed.”
Other names mentioned by education leaders:
- Darin Brawley, superintendent of Compton Unified.
- Nancy Albarran, superintendent ofSan Jose Unified.
- Austin Beutner, former superintendent of Los Angeles Unified and businessman.
- Matt Navo, executive director of the California Collaborative for Education Excellence and former superintendent of Sanger Unified.
- John Deasy, former superintendent of several school districts, including Los Angeles Unified.
- Marshall Tuck, CEO of EdVoice, a non-profit education advocacy organization.
- Garth Lewis, Yolo County Superintendent of Schools.
- Kyla Johnson-Trammell, CEO of Oakland Thrives and former superintendent of Oakland Unified.
- Gabriela Mafi, superintendent ofGarden Grove Unified.
- Ted Alejandre, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools.

EdSource is California’s largest independent newsroom focused on education.













