The name might sound like a great place to eat, but Cornish Heights was part of the building boom that transformed Point Loma into a desirable place to live in the 1920s. 

A vintage newspaper advertisement for Cornish Heights, featuring a bold headline, Bay View and City View labels, property details, and a contact box. Its formal real estate promotion conveys an early 20th-century tone.
A Nov. 27, 1926, advertisement in The Beach News announcing the opening of Cornish Heights, a new Point Loma subdivision offering 40 estates, modern improvements and views of San Diego Bay. (Courtesy of The Beach News via California Revealed.)

By 1926, developers were promoting a new way of life. One of the subdivisions being developed was Cornish Heights, which was at the top of the Point Loma peninsula, offering amazing views of San Diego, the bay, and Coronado. 

On Nov. 27, 1926, the John P. Mills organization announced in a story in the Beach News newspaper that the new subdivision would open for sale the following day, Nov. 28, at 3 p.m. “New development of 40 estates in Cornish Heights. High-class restricted development. Modern improvements. Grand view. Call for further information on prices, site and maps.”

Cornish Heights was part of a large development by John P. Mills and his associates, including Alexander Pantages, a theatrical businessman, and Jesse H. Shreve, a prominent San Diego banker. They operated through Pantages, Mills, Shreve & Co. and the John P. Mills Organization. 

The land had previously been associated with Albert Goodwill Spalding, the baseball and sporting goods magnate. A 1975 newspaper interview with Mills recounts his purchase of 300 acres of Sunset Cliffs property from Spalding. The developers subsequently expanded their Point Loma projects through several subdivisions. The developers wanted to create a beautiful area with paved streets, sidewalks, curbs, lighting, and other services. 

They promoted the area as a Mediterranean-style housing development with beautiful Spanish-style homes, stucco-covered homes, and red-roofed homes. To encourage people to purchase the land, the Mills organization set up large tents and provided free food, speeches, and promotional activities. 

Prospective buyers were also offered boat trips around San Diego Bay. They even arranged a special train to bring potential buyers from Los Angeles, Mills said in the February 1975 interview.

“[I] put them under a big tent like at an evangelist meeting, fed them and lectured them about San Diego,” Mills told the San Diego Union newspaper at the time. “It didn’t take long to make a sale — 10 percent down and the balance over five years.”

The interview was reproduced as part of the report submitted to the City of San Diego in 2019 for Mills’ home — which lists his wife Elizabeth as the architect — to nominate it as a Historical Resource.

The development was progressing quickly, and in January 1927 the Union reported that work was being done on Riviera Villas and other areas of Point Loma. Cornish Heights was among the new subdivisions being added to the development.  

Unfortunately, the real estate boom didn’t last long. Following the stock market crash in 1929 and the Great Depression, property owners began defaulting on their payments, and the Mills organization experienced serious financial difficulties. The organization returned to Los Angeles in 1930, although its associates continued trying to sell properties in the area for years afterward.

The original names of the subdivisions, such as Cornish Heights, Riviera Villas, and Azure Vista, aren’t as well known by many locals as they once were.

The advertisement from 1926 gives us an idea of what was on offer 100 years ago. A beautiful area to build your dream home on the top of the peninsula with amazing views and a perfectly planned area.

Read more history stories here. Do you have a story to tell? Send an email to DebbieSklar@cox.net.

Sources: