On Monday, the San Diego City Council voted 7-0 to shut off the city’s police license plate cameras and start ending its contract with Flock, the company that runs them. Seven votes are enough to overturn a veto if Mayor Todd Gloria tries to keep the cameras. Councilmember Stephen Whitburn, whose district has the most cameras, said he believed they were not being used to help immigration agents, but that his belief could not calm the fear he hears from immigrant families. That is the real problem: even supporters can only ask us to trust them.

Picture a woman who called police because someone at home was hurting her, then learned detectives had used cameras across the city to follow her car. Voice of San Diego reported last week that San Diego police did this while investigating one of their own officers, tracking both him and the woman. The department said it followed its rules and has done the same in six other internal investigations.

Opinion logo

I believe officers should be watched, too. After a California Highway Patrol officer murdered college student Cara Knott in 1986, Bill Kolender, who later became sheriff, pushed for a law putting trackers on patrol cars, and officers knew the rules. Quietly turning cameras on an officer, and pulling a victim into the search, is very different.

These cameras photograph the license plate of every passing car, with the time and place. Some are on poles, and others ride on patrol cars or hide inside units that look like traffic cones. Over time, they build a record of where each of us goes, whether that’s to work, to a church, mosque or synagogue, or to the doctor.

We were told the cameras were for serious crimes, but San Diego police later admitted Border Patrol and immigration agents had been allowed to run nearly 13,000 searches of the city’s cameras. After Times of San Diego found that officers listed only “other” as the reason for nearly 4,000 searches this year, the department removed that choice.

San Diego’s vote doesn’t end the problem. Drive into La Mesa, Chula Vista or El Cajon, and you are still on camera and searchable by agencies across the state. I live in La Mesa, so I asked the city for its search records. In two months, more than 300 outside agencies searched La Mesa’s cameras about 885,000 times. At first the city blacked out every reason, until Police Chief Ray Sweeney, to his credit, stopped that.

When the reasons came out, most explained very little. They were usually a case number or a short legal code, which could mean a stolen car, an investigation of an officer or a favor for federal agents, and no one outside can tell which.

La Mesa is trying to do better. It will soon require outside agencies to sign an agreement to give a reason for every search. As Lt. Travis Higgins told Times of San Diego, safety and public trust “go hand in hand.”

SANDAG, our regional planning agency, runs a police database and sells access to at least nine federal agencies for more than $600,000 a year, including about $401,000 from immigration investigators. SANDAG told me it has never checked what those agencies search for. Families watching federal agents separate parents from their children deserve to know whether the cameras on their street are helping.

Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill to limit these cameras in 2025, and its author, state Sen. Sabrina Cervantes, plans to try again next year with a version requiring a case number for every search. That would help, but La Mesa shows that a number by itself still leaves the public guessing, and misusing this information often isn’t even a crime.

California needs a law that makes every search easy to understand. Each should carry a plain reason from one statewide list, such as “stolen car” or “missing person,” along with a case number that an independent reviewer can check. When an officer searches for another agency, including a federal one, the record should say who asked. Departments should publish how many searches they run and why, and tracking someone for a wrong reason should be a crime.

We don’t have to wait for Sacramento. The state board that sets police training rules could create one standard for explaining searches. And here at home, our police chiefs, the sheriff and the district attorney have agreed on shared rules before, and they can do the same for these cameras.

I spent 35 years in law enforcement and was an early supporter of these cameras, so I know that “trust us” is not enough. San Diego’s council reached the same conclusion on Monday, and now the rest of our county and our state should follow.

David A. Myers is a retired commander in the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office with 35 years of service. He served as director of safety and security at Jewish Family Service of San Diego from 2023 to 2025.