• Facebook
  • Google Plus
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter

Menu

Skip to content
  • About
  • Staff
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Advertise
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
Header image

Times of San DiegoLogo

Local News and Opinion for San Diego

Menu

Skip to content
  • All
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Education
  • Arts
  • Military
  • Tech
  • Life
  • Opinion
Search Thousands of San Diego Jobs
  • Miramar Marines Pepare for 'Winter Fury' Exercise Across Southern California
  • California Democrats Liken Newsom Recall Effort to Extremist ‘Coup’
  • San Diego County Reports 3,027 New COVID-19 Cases and 28 More Deaths
  • Motorcyclist Killed on Northbound I-5 Near Las Pulgas Canyon Road
  • For Los Angeles Ambulance Crews, the COVID-19 Calls Never Stop

Home » Opinion » This Article

Opinion: Incident at SDSU Highlights Growing Anti-Semitism in Progressive Circles

Posted by Editor on May 18, 2019 in Opinion | 4015 Views
| Comments | Leave a Comment
Share This Article:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail
Poster calling for Palestine to be free
Screenshot of poster-like image from email newsletter sent by the San Diego State University Women’s Resource Center.

By Peter C. Herman

On May 8, the Women’s Resource Center at San Diego State University sent out a newsletter featuring announcements for lectures, courses from the Women’s Studies Department, and other items of interest. But at the bottom of the email, a student inserted a poster-like image of woman with a gun and the language “From the river to the sea Palestine will be free.”

Support Times of San Diego's growth
with a small monthly contribution

Become a supporter

Coming on the heels of the Poway shooting, the inclusion of this image seems especially shocking. But how are we to respond to a glorification of violence in a university-sanctioned newsletter?

As I’ve frequently, and publicly, affirmed the importance of the First Amendment, banning such images is not an option, no matter how offensive. Instead, let’s unpack this image’s content.

First, the woman holding the AK-47 is Leilah Khaled, the world’s first female airplane hijacker. She belongs to a group called the Palestinian Front for the Liberation of Palestine, (PFLP) which from the late 1960s has engaged in various forms of terrorist violence, the most recent being a drive-by shooting in June 2015 that killed one person and injured three others. Khaled participated in two hijackings in 1969 and 1970.

The second attempt was foiled in mid-air, and the plane diverted to Heathrow. Although the British government arrested Khaled, they released her after the PFLP hijacked another plane and the British government traded Khaled for hostages.

Since then, Leilah Khaled has become something of a folk hero, and she has far from renounced Opinion logoviolence. In 2014, Khaled stated the Second Intifada failed “because the leadership was not brave enough at that time to escalate the intifada, to take it to another level.”

Given the level of carnage inflicted by the Palestinians, including multiple suicide bombings, such as the Sbarro pizza restaurant massacre, it’s hard to imagine what taking “it to another level” might mean, but you can be sure the body count would be very, very high.

Next, the phrase “From the river to the sea Palestine will be free” is frequently invoked by proponents of the Palestinian cause. The river is the Jordan River, and the sea is of course the Mediterranean. Essentially, the phrase means that the Palestinians want all the territory the state of Israel presently occupies. The phrase, in other words, calls for the eradication of a sovereign state. Needless to say, the present Jewish inhabitants will not exactly be welcomed.

In 1984, Abu Iyad, leader of the terrorist group Black September, which carried out the 1972 Munich Olympics Massacre, stated on Radio Amman: “The Zionists took Palestine inch by inch. And we must retrieve it inch by inch. We believe that Palestine, from the river to the sea, is our country.” 

Article 12 of the Fatah constitution (they are the largest of the groups making up the Palestine Liberation Organization, and the first to launch terrorist attacks against Israel), is even more explicit: “Complete liberation of Palestine, and eradication of Zionist economic, political, military and cultural existence.”

Recently, Hamas political leader Fathi Hammad stated his intentions concerning Israel as bluntly as possible: “The day of your slaughter, extermination and annihilation has drawn near … You should search for a place in Europe, in hell, or in the ocean or the Bermuda Triangle because there is no place for you in [here] or anywhere.”

So the image that appeared in the Women’s Resource Center newsletter endorses both terrorism and genocide.  

How has SDSU responded? On the one hand, J. Luke Wood, the Chief Diversity Officer and Associate Vice President for Faculty Diversity and Inclusion (SDSU likes long titles for their administrators) sprang into action. He had the WRC take down the newsletter and issue an apology. He has also spoken to several local rabbis, and has promised further action over the summer. On the other hand, President Adela de la Torre has so far remained silent, even though she responded very quickly after similar racist incidents in the recent past.

Unfortunately, the WRC’s use of this image provides yet another example of how anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism have become acceptable in progressive circles. To give but two examples, several leaders of the Women’s March, have expressed their admiration for noted Jew-hater, Louis Farrakhan. The student government at Williams College recently tried to deny recognition to a pro-Israel student group (the decision was reversed), even though Students for Justice in Palestine had no difficulties.

In his excellent book, Contemporary Left Antisemitism, noted University of London sociologist David Hirsh examines the hatred of Jews “within that part of the elite which thinks of itself as progressive” (such as the WCR), but notes that “this elite anti-Semitism has failed to energize much of a mob.” Maybe in the UK. But in the United States, the mob has most certainly been energized, as anti-Semitic incidents have rocketed since Donald Trump’s election.

None of which is to say that the Palestinian case is entirely without merit. As Ari Shavit writes in My Promised Land, the Nakba (the Catastrophe), represented by the expulsion of Arabs from Lydda (renamed “Lod”) is Zionism’s “black box,” its “dark secret.”  When the Jewish forces banished the Arabs from Lydda (renamed Lod), the military governor “watches the faces of the people marching into exile, he wonders if there is a Jeremiah among them to lament their calamity and disgrace.”

Even so, advocating the elimination of the entire state of Israel is not a feasible solution. That the WRC seems to think so, and sides with terrorists advocating genocide, is not only deeply unfortunate, but illustrates how the overlap of anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism has become unexceptional even among the supposedly educated. This is not likely to end well.

Peter C. Herman is a professor of English Literature at San Diego State University. He works on Shakespeare, Milton, and the literature of terrorism. He is the editor of the recent book Critical Concepts: Terrorism and Literature.

Opinion: Incident at SDSU Highlights Growing Anti-Semitism in Progressive Circles was last modified: May 19th, 2019 by Editor

>> Subscribe to Times of San Diego’s free daily email newsletter! Click here

Follow Us:
Facebooktwitterrss
Posted in Opinion | Tagged anti-Semitism, genocide, Israel, Jordan River, Leilah Khaled, Palestinians, Peter Herman, progressives, San Diego State University, terrorism, Women's Resource Center
Search Thousands of San Diego Jobs

Get Times of San Diego by Email

Our free newsletter is delivered at 8 a.m. daily.


Most Popular Today

  • New CDC Data Shows How San Diego County Ranks Nationally in the Pandemic New CDC Data Shows How San Diego County Ranks Nationally in the Pandemic 1,370 views
  • MarketInk: Prolific Announcer Hangs Up Microphone After 2,000 Games Over 35 Years MarketInk: Prolific Announcer Hangs Up Microphone After 2,000 Games Over 35 Years 1,010 views
  • Opinion: Santee's Dustin Trotter Should Resign as Backer of D.C. Insurrectionists Opinion: Santee’s Dustin Trotter Should Resign as Backer of D.C. Insurrectionists 710 views
  • California Democrats Liken Newsom Recall Effort to Extremist ‘Coup’ California Democrats Liken Newsom Recall Effort to Extremist ‘Coup’ 630 views
  • San Diego Residents 65+ Are Next in Line for Vaccine, But Supplies Still Limited San Diego Residents 65+ Are Next in Line for Vaccine, But Supplies Still Limited 510 views

©®2021 Times of San Diego LLC

Menu

  • About
  • Staff
  • Contact
  • Support
  • Advertise
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service