Today’s newsletter is presented by Kaiser Permanente.


Hello, Uptown!

Flock has been the talk of the town lately, from ACLU lawsuits to wrongful arrests, not to mention a surge of nationwide backlash to the surveillance system.

Monday, the council voted to shut down the city’s automated license plate reader program. Along with ALPRs they also decided to not approve the city’s Smart Streetlights. That decision came about because the contract with Ubicquia and Flock includes both of those technologies. If the council decided to approve the use of Smart Streetlights, the contract could have been renegotiated, rather than cancelled.

I’ve been following the technology in our city for some time now. If you have been too, this council decision wasn’t entirely surprising as backing for the cameras massively fell off among the remaining supporters on the council in the days up to the vote.

This was because of a report from Voice of San Diego showing the cameras were used in an internal investigation, and part of that investigation involved an officers conduct with a domestic violence victim.

Despite the decision being somewhat preordained, I think it’s worth noting this likely would not have been possible mere months ago. The tides of public opinion have made an impact on our elected officials, and the documentation from local reporting of how this technology is being used. My colleague Dorian Hargrove and I recently wrote about a 19-year-old who was shot in a car that, his boss says, was not stolen, but was flagged by an ALPR as such.

Instances like that were brought up in the council meeting by citizens wanting to see the technology put to rest. Seeing the impact of our reporting was fascinating as I watched the public comments period, so I guess this is a thank you for following along too.

In our Uptown area, Hillcrest had the highest concentration of ALPRs. Our Drew Sitton brought some nuance to this issue, highlighting the community of LGBTQ+ people who say the cameras have helped solve and protect them from hate crimes, which certainly are a threat to the community here. There are two sides of this issue, especially as the cameras can serve as an effective public safety tool because they are capable of watching at all times.

As with any cultural group in society, opinions aren’t uniform. On the other side of the coin, there are LGBTQ+ people who believe the answer to safety isn’t to have the government watch them at all times. The same way being constantly watched can create a sense of safety for some, it can create fear in others. It wasn’t too far in the past that the government would track gay and gender non-conforming people to charge them with ‘degeneracy.’

In an era of high-tech policing and widespread adoption of AI-powered tools, debates like these are going to stick around. While our contract with Ubicquia and Flock is in the process of being terminated, there is the possibility this door isn’t locked. We could follow in Los Angeles’ footsteps. They cancelled their contract with Flock and moved on to Axon, another company that runs an ALPR database system. Time will tell how the council and city decide to proceed, but I’ll be sure to follow along.

Let me know your thoughts on the issue: tessab@timesofsandiego.com

Tessa Balc

Uptown News newsletter host


Uptown story spotlight

After Flock came to Hillcrest, hate crimes dropped. The community is now divided on whether ALPRs should stay. 

By Drew Sitton • Times of San Diego

Hate crimes in Hillcrest have dropped since 2025. Some attribute the decline to the introduction of Automated License Plate Readers in July 2024.


Uptown News thanks our corporate sponsors. Find out more about sponsorships and advertising opportunities here.



More Uptown news


Uptown News thanks our corporate sponsors. Find out more about sponsorships and advertising opportunities here.