A Chula Vista police officer charged with misdemeanor manslaughter for allegedly running a red light while on duty, resulting in the death of a motorcyclist, was granted misdemeanor diversion Monday,
The decision would result in his case being dismissed if he completes the terms of the court’s order.
Johan Jacobo, 29, is charged with turning left against a red arrow at Windingwalk Street and Olympic Parkway on June 20, 2025. Simon Robledo, 28, crashed into the officer’s patrol vehicle. He died at a hospital about an hour later.
Jacobo was responding to a call, but did not have his lights or sirens activated when he made the turn, according to prosecutors.
Jacobo faced up to one year in county jail if convicted of the misdemeanor count, but with diversion granted by a judge, his case could be dismissed if he successfully completes the diversion program.
The program includes 150 hours of volunteer work, completion of a defensive driving course and 20 therapy sessions, paying restitution and a public apology letter to the victim’s family. The terms must be completed over the course of a 24-month diversionary period.
Jacobo remains out of custody on his own recognizance. He will return to court in April to gauge his progress in complying with the program terms.
Jacobo’s defense attorney, Vishad Dewan, argued in a diversion motion filed last month that his client was a good candidate for the program due to a lack of criminal history or likelihood to re-offend.
The attorney also wrote that Jacobo “remains profoundly affected by the loss of life resulting from this accident” and is “deeply mindful of Mr. Robledo’s family and the loss that they have endured.”
Additionally, the motion claimed that per a defense-retained accident reconstruction expert, other factors besides Jacobo’s left turn may have also contributed to the fatality, including the motorcycle’s speed – which the motion stated was between 89 to 98 miles per hour – and roadway visibility issues.
The attorney wrote that center median landscaping and the road’s curvature may have prevented Jacobo and Robledo from seeing one another until the last moment.
The San Diego County District Attorney’s Office opposed granting diversion and in its written opposition, argued that the nature of the offense was too serious to warrant diversion.
Prosecutors also highlighted Jacobo’s role as a police officer, writing, “Defendant was entrusted with the responsibility of protecting the public and enforcing all laws. When he chose to make that illegal turn, he failed to uphold this responsibility, as well as his duty to drive with `due regard for the safety of all persons.”‘
The prosecution’s motion also contained a letter from Robledo’s mother, Linda Ramirez, who argued diversion would “allow the defendant to escape true legal accountability and continue working in a position of authority without facing the consequences of his actions.”
Robledo’s family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Jacobo and the city of Chula Vista, which requested a pause on the civil case until the criminal proceedings are completed.
Superior Court Judge Enrique Camarena said he could not find any grounds to deny diversion, as misdemeanor manslaughter was not one of the crimes excluded under the law. Among the crimes that are ineligible for diversion are sex offenses, domestic violence and stalking.
Camarena said Jacobo met the diversion statute criteria. He also has no criminal record and “a significant, positive law enforcement career record,” the judge said.
Jacobo’s defense attorney opposed the apology letter diversion term as it could be used against Jacobo in the civil case.
The judge set aside the concern and said, “Should he apologize for that? I think the answer is yes, in terms of the diversionary portion of the conditions. It might not be helpful in a civil case, but I don’t think that’s my goal.”
