San Diego jeweler Leo Hamel, a Republican candidate for state Assembly, says he joined the controversial Church of Scientology at age 18 or 19 but hasn’t taken part in church functions since the early 2000s.
“The Scientology question is a fair one,” Eric Andersen said in a comment. “Although religion should not be a test for office, it helps us understand the ideas our representatives will uphold.”
Hamel hasn’t posted a comment on the blog about Scientology, he told Times of San Diego, “because it’s a lose-lose for me.”
“I’m a good guy. I do nothing but help people in this community. I donate to tons of charities,” he said Wednesday in a phone interview. “I haven’t been to a [Scientology] service … in at least 10 years, maybe 15.”
But he still took offense.
“The fact that we’re discussing somebody’s religion seems kind of against everything that we’re supposed to be standing for these days,” Hamel said. “No matter where my position is on Scientology, it’s still a religion. And it would be inappropriate to discuss someone’s religion — completely inappropriate.”
Agreeing was Santee Mayor Randy Voepel, who entered the 71st District Assembly race a year ago.
On Tuesday, Voepel said via email: “I never comment about another person’s religion or beliefs.”
But a third candidate, science-fiction author and Union Bank executive Tony Teora, said Hamel’s affiliation is not important “unless his legislation is based on some things (in Scientology) that I don’t think are very good. They don’t believe in standard medicine.”
In an online comment, one-time La Mesa mayor candidate Craig Maxwell said: “Religion shouldn’t be a test for office. Quack cults like Scientology, on the other hand, are another matter altogether and shouldn’t be ignored.”
Teora said Hamel called him several days ago, and Teora asked the TV figure “point-blank” if he was a Scientology member.
“He was very careful about his answer,” said Teora, 52, a Julian resident. “He said that he’s a Christian and that he’s going to Christian schools, and he used Scientology’s business study program.”
Hamel “really didn’t answer the question” about his current status in the church, Teora said in a phone interview Wednesday.
Even so, Teora said Hamel’s past ties to the church will be a “challenge” to him in a conservative district. “I don’t want somebody in my district who is going to say: Hey, I’m not going to support legislation for doctors and medicines because …. the cult says we shouldn’t have medicines.”
She says Hamel may have hinted his science stance in a July 2005 Union-Tribune letter to the editor talking about Tom Cruise, a high-profile Scientologist.
Hamel wrote: “Cruise may have been a trifle aggressive, but psychotropic drugs are an important subject. The billions made by the drug companies do not, in my mind, justify the drugging of a major portion of our culture.”
Wachter said the letter suggests that Hamel in 2005 was a Scientologist, “publicly supporting Cruise and denouncing psychiatry. At the very least, he still seemed to be in agreement with Scientology’s hostility to psychiatry.”
Also noted on sdrostra was a 2006 World Institute of Scientology Enterprise business directory that included Hamel.
Hamel says he can’t explain how he’s in the directory.
“I don’t think I ever paid to be in there,” he said. “The church doesn’t have its own directory. I may have paid once, like back in 2001 or in the 1990s. And someone … left my name in the directory so it looks fuller, so they could sell more ads.”
Based on references to Hamel in Scientology publications, “he doesn’t strike me as a terribly gung-ho Scientologist,” Wachter says. “I don’t see any completions of the L’s (L10, L11, L12, extremely expensive services that wealthy Scientologists often do), and I don’t see any OT levels.”
She said the lack of entries for Hamel after 2000 could mean that his involvement dropped off or stopped completely.
“It could also mean that he’s still involved, but his completions aren’t being listed,” she said, noting that he “went Clear in 1979,” a state open to different interpretations.
Penelope Hamel, the candidate’s wife, also has Scientology connections.
“If she’s also known as Penny, she’s also done an Ethics Specialist Course, which suggests she may have been on staff at some point,” Wachter told Times of San Diego.
Hamel confirmed that Penny, his wife, “may have been a [church] volunteer for a few months.”
Commenters on sdrostra debated whether and how Hamel left the church.
Anderson alleged that Hamel was kicked out of the Scientology church in the early 2000s by the office of the Chairman of the Board “because he questioned him and his practices. He has been ‘dead-filed’ ever since.”
But Wachter said: “If he was causing enough trouble for [David] Miscavige to get kicked out, he would probably have been declared a Suppressive Person and therefore a Potential Trouble Source to his wife, who would have been pressured to disconnect from him if he couldn’t be ‘handled’ and routed back into Scientology’s good graces.
“That’s the reason I brought up Penelope’s involvement — her ongoing involvement suggests (but certainly does not prove) his ongoing involvement.”
Voepel has been questioned as well, since he publicly left the Republican Party in 2010. Registrar of Voters Michael Vu says Voepel rejoined the GOP in January 2015 “when he re-registered to vote and selected his preference with the Republican Party.”
Said Voepel via email: “I initially left the party out of frustration that the national establishment was nominating candidates who I felt were insufficiently conservative. Ultimately, I decided that I could do a better job of electing conservatives by working within the party rather than outside of it, which is what motivated my re-registering as Republican.”
As of Monday, the San Diego County Republican Party has yet to endorse anyone in the 71st District race, representing much of East County and parts of southern Riverside County.
Hamel said most churches don’t have a “formal document that you can show that says whether I’m in or I’m out. The [Church of Scientology] is unpopular in the minds of a lot of people. But it’s still a religion of a lot of people.”
Teora, soundly defeated by incumbent Assemblyman Brian Jones in the November 2014 election (72 percent to 28 percent), hopes to do better against the 15-year Santee mayor and diamond-buying jeweler.
Teora said that Hamel “seems like a decent guy. But I do think if he’s hiding his membership in Scientology — and if he actually follows that belief system — I think the voters should at least know that.”