Rescue Horses Not Welcome at Valley Center Parade Over Infection Fears

Share This Article:
A horse gallops within a fenced enclosure at HiCaliber Horse Rescue in Valley Center on March 2, 2018. (Brandon Quester/inewsource)

Nicole Tyau | inewsource

inewsource is an independent and nonprofit journalism organization in San Diego, and relies on grants and philanthropists to support its investigative content. Click here to learn more.

HiCaliber Horse Rescue has been asked not to bring its horses to the Valley Center Western Days Parade on Saturday because of concerns some of its horses have a highly contagious equine disease called strangles.

Support Times of San Diego's growth
with a small monthly contribution

The decision was made following a Western Days board meeting Monday night that more than a dozen people attended at the Valley Center library. Most were there to oppose HiCaliber’s participation in the parade.

“I do not believe at this point in time they are planning on bringing any horses if they march in the parade,” Gina Roberts, president of the event’s board, said Tuesday. “I am hoping they make the appropriate choice.”

HiCaliber announced on April 21 it was shutting down amid multiple government investigations into allegations of fraud, animal abuse and improper veterinary practices involving the nonprofit. Even so, HiCaliber had planned to have its horses march in Saturday’s parade.

Though the parade’s website on Tuesday no longer listed HiCaliber as a participant, Roberts told inewsource that was a mistake. She said the rescue still has a valid application on file and can “choose to participate in another way.”

She did not elaborate on what that other way would be. But she said if HiCaliber brought horses to the parade, a decision would be made at that time on what action to take.

Lisa Burkhard was one of the people who asked the Western Days board to exclude HiCaliber’s horses from participating in the parade.

Burkhard, 56, told inewsource she first rode in the parade when she was 7 and has continued over the years to participate. But if HiCaliber horses are part of this year’s event, her horses won’t be.

“We don’t believe they’re responsible horse owners,” Burkhard said.

In-depth San Diego news: Sign up for the inewsource newsletter today

The concerns raised by Burkhard and the others at the meeting stem from an inewsource story in March in which former HiCaliber volunteers detailed how strangles was prevalent at the Valley Center ranch, and that it was not being disclosed to anyone outside the organization.

Strangles is an upper respiratory equine disease that is highly contagious but manageable if properly contained. The group of former volunteers provided photos, screenshots, internal HiCaliber documents and veterinary records to inewsource and authorities investigating the nonprofit.

HiCaliber’s founder Michelle Knuttila told inewsource in March that some HiCaliber horses contracted the disease last year, but it’s “not that big of a deal in California.”

Chief Steve MacKinnon of the San Diego Humane Society told inewsource Tuesday that investigators have found no evidence of the disease during recent visits to the ranch.

“We’ve been in contact with the state vets and with the vets that have been working with HiCaliber, and we haven’t seen any issues right now having to do with strangles,” MacKinnon said.

Sean Jones, an attorney for HiCaliber, said at Monday’s Western Days meeting that if the board specifically prevented the horse rescue from participating, it would be grounds for “a constitutional lawsuit.”

Mike Shore, division chief with the Valley Center Fire Protection District, also told the board that the agency is concerned about sanitary conditions at the HiCaliber ranch. He described “tons and tons and tons” of horse manure on the property.

“They have not made any efforts in the last three months to clean that up that we’re aware of,” Shore said.

A San Diego County spokesman told inewsource last week that HiCaliber failed to reduce the number of horses on its property to 138 by April 30, as required under a compliance schedule. That resulted in a $100 citation. A follow-up inspection in mid-May found HiCaliber had reduced its numbers to 131, and the nonprofit has until July 30 to cut that number to 113.

Follow Us: